Here’s How Rich People Are Using High-End Pawn Shops
by Libby Kane Sep. 11, 2014, 2:29 PM
The term “pawn shop” tends to summon mental images of a seedy strip mall storefront dealing in Grandma’s jewelry and signed baseball cards.
That’s why Paul Aitken, CEO of asset lending site Borro, doesn’t use it to describe his company.
“We’re about as similar to a private bank as we are to a pawn shop,” Aitken explains. “We provide an average loan of around $15,000, which is very different from the average $150 loans that pawn shops provide.”
The typical loan amount isn’t the only difference between Borro and the old-school pawn shop. High net-worth individuals are discovering that the service, which allows users to manage transactions online, is a convenient way to get cash, in a method that works for them.
On the surface, asset lending and pawn shop models are extremely similar: The borrower applies to the lender for a loan based on the value of a given asset, and as collateral, hands over that asset to the lender for safe keeping. The borrower then pays back the loan, with interest, and takes back the asset (or doesn’t pay, and forfeits their collateral for the lender to sell).
In the case of a standard pawn shop, the asset might be a pair of sterling silver cuff links. At Borro, it might be an Aston Martin.
Henry LawfordAn Andy Warhol Mao print secured a loan for $21,000.
Borro, which operates in the U.S. and the U.K. with offices in New York City and London, deals in luxury goods, including diamonds, fine art, antiques, and even more unusual valuables like Oscar and Grammy awards and Olympic gold medals.
In particular, Aitken remembers a $250,000 loan for a Stradivarius violin, $1.2 million for a signed Monet, an Andy Warhol Mao print for $21,000, and even a collection of 12th- and 13th-century swords and armor for $325,000.
A little larger scale than Grandma’s pearls.
Borro loans are capped at $2 million, and the company itself has raised over $152 million since its founding in 2008. It’s probably the most well-known of its kind, and attracts customers through everything from newspaper ads to partnerships with wealth managers and private banks.
High-end pawn shops aren’t common, per se, but Borro isn’t alone in the space. Similar companies that have made headlines include New York Loan and Suttons & Robertson.
Aitken says the interest rates on Borro loans are typically between 2.5% and 4% a month, compared to pawn shop rates that tend to range from 5% to 25%, depending on the state. (Traditional pawn shops might also charge fees for things like lost tickets or storage.) Only 10% of borrowers don’t repay their loans in full, and of those, he estimates, half never intended to take back their assets.
“A lot of people come to us who are self-employed with irregular cash flows,” Aitken explains. “Banks don’t like irregular cash flows. These are people who are looking for loans for opportunistic reasons — not distressed reasons — and they just need liquidity to do it. Over half of the loans are business-related.”
Most of Borro’s clients, he continues, are small-business owners, property developers, or people working in sports or media with short-term contracts.
The average Borro client takes out four loans, prioritizing the ease of borrowing over the price. “They’re paying for speed and quality of service,” Aitken says. “People who consume luxury goods are more sensitive to quality than price.”
Aitken explains that clients come to Borro instead of seeking alternate forms of financing for three main reasons: The transaction is quick; there’s no material credit risk (Borro does a background check to confirm your identity, but no credit check); and in many cases it’s cheaper than selling the valuables outright.
“If you sell an asset, you lose 30% of the value in the costs of selling,” Aitken says. “The clients who come to us realize that. Otherwise, you just sell.”